DAILY MAINS NEWSLETTER FOR UPSC |20 Feb 2021| RaghukulCS

Daily Mains Newsletter For UPSC
| RaghukulCS

19 FEB 2021

Index

Mains Value Addition

Mains Analysis

Topic No

Topic Name

Source

1

A verdict that has ended a long silence.

 The Hindu

2

Too many IITs, unrealistic expectations.

The Hindu

3

The Quad endures

Indian Express

Mains Value Addition

Sexual harassment at workplace remains a problem of institutions, not individuals

Syllabus –

GS-2: Role of women and women’s organization and Social empowerment.

Analysis: –

  • The Ramani verdict is a huge moral vindication of the #MeToo movement, and will, hopefully, serve to deter powerful men from using the defamation law to silence survivors. 
  • In the media and social media, it is the cases involving well-known individual men that tend to receive attention. But sexual harassment is a problem of institutions rather than of individuals alone. The world over, employers deploy sexual harassment as a means to discipline and control women workers.

Crimes reduced by 16%from 2019’

Syllabus –

GS-2: Important aspects of governance, transparency and accountability

Analysis: –

  • According to the data, 2,66,070 Indian Penal Code cases were registered in 2020 as against 3,16,261 in 2019, showing a decline of 15.87%. Police Control Room calls in 2020 were 18,08,384 calls as compared to 29,25,531 in 2019, showing a decline of 38.19%, the data stated.
  • While all the reported crimes saw a decline last year, snatching and robbery cases increased by11% and .36% respectively. A total of 1,963 robbery cases were registered in 2020 as opposed to 1,956 in 2019. A total of 7,965 snatching cases were registered in 2020 as opposed to 6,266 in 2019.
  • Motor vehicle theft saw a decline of 24.23% with 35,019 cases registered in 2020 and 46,215 registered in 2019. Dacoity witnessed a decline of 40% with nine cases registered last year as opposed to 15 in 2019.

Make private traders pay MSP: Kisan Sabha

Syllabus –

  GS-3: Issues related to direct and indirect farm subsidies and minimum support prices; Public Distribution System objectives

Analysis: –

Corporates should share agribusiness profits with primary producers, it says. Minimum support prices for farm produce should be paid by private traders, not just the government, the All-India Kisan Sabha said on Friday.

PM Narendra Modi asks Visva Bharati to help farmers access global market

Syllabus –

  GS-2: Issues relating to development and management of Social Sector/Services relating to Education

Analysis: –

  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi Friday praised the world view of poet- philosopher Rabindranath Tagore and asked Visva-Bharati students to help farmers and artisans of nearby villages find global markets.
  • He said Guru Rabindranath Tagore had not envisioned the university as a typical educational institution but one that will help Indian culture realise its full potential globally.
  • Addressing online the convocation of Visva Bharati university that was launched by Nobel laureate Tagore in 1921 and designated the first central university in 1951, Modi said knowledge was not a “still and static but a dynamic concept”.

Mains Analysis

A verdict that has ended a long silence.

Why in News: –

A Delhi court acquitted / free former journalist Priya Ramani in a defamation case filed by former Union minister MJ Akbar against after she accused him of sexual harassment.

Syllabus:

GS-2: Role of women and women’s organization and Social empowerment.

  • The Priya Ramani case is a key moment in the legal process that has often failed to bring justice to women complainants.
  • The court said that a woman has the right to voice grievance several years after the alleged crime took place.

What are the important highlights from the SC verdict?

  1. The court observed that you don’t have to touch someone inappropriately to sexually harass them.
  2. A woman who was sexually harassed had to prove her motives, that she was not guilty of defamation and was not making false allegations.
  3. Now all workplaces have to have Prevention of Sexual Harassment at the Workplace (POSH) complaint cells but women are still wary for this very reason.
  4. The court says women have a right to speak about their experiences on any platform, even decades later.
  5. Court says “A woman cannot be punished “for raising voice against sex abuse on the pretext of criminal complaint of defamation.
  6. The imputation is made in good faith for the protection of the interests of the person making it, or of any other person, or for the public good.”

 The laws and defence:

  • Under the Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC)as whoever, by words either spoken or intended to be read, or by signs or by visible representations, makes or publishes any imputation concerning any person intending to harm, or knowing or having reason to believe that such imputation.
  • The law of criminal defamation is premised on a person’sright to a reputation. Making or publishing “any imputation concerning any person, intending to harm, or knowing or having reason to believe that such imputation will harm, the reputation of such person”, is criminal defamation.
  • Akbar alleged that Ms. Ramani’s allegations, “by their very tone and tenor, are ex facie defamatory and had not only damaged the complainant’s goodwill and reputation in his social circles and on the political stage, which was established after years of hard work.
  • Ramani premised her defenceon the First Exception to Section 499 which postulates that “It is not defamation to impute anything which is true concerning any person, if it be for the public good that the imputation should be made or published.
  • Ramani also relied upon the” Ninth Exception” which says that,“It is not defamation to make an imputation on the character of another provided that the imputation be made in good faith for the protection of the interests of the person making it, or of any other person, or for the public good.”
  • The Third Exception was also pressed into service saying: “It is not defamation to express in good faith any opinion whatever respecting the conduct of any person touching any public question, and respecting his character, so far as his character appears in that conduct”.
  • The court accepted the “defence of the accused that she disclosed the truth regarding the incident of sexual harassment against on ground public goods.
  • The judgment has thus ruled that Ms. Ramani spoke the truth, and that Mr. Akbar had a pre-existing tarnished reputation which had been exposed for the public good.

 The Construction and Law in IPC provision:

  1. Article 15(1) The Construction provides that the state shall not discriminate against any citizen of India on the ground of sex.
  2. Article 39(a) The Construction provides the state to secure for men and women equally the right to an adequate means of livelihood.
  3. Indian Constitution guarantees several rights such as the right to equality in Article 14, right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of Constitution to all its citizens irrespective of gender.
  4. Section 500 of IPC, which is on punishment for defamation, reads, “Whoever defames another shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both.”
  5. Section 509 IPC provides that whoever, intending to insult the modesty of any woman, utters any word, makes any sound or gesture, or exhibits any object, intending that such word or sound shall be heard, or that such gesture or object shall be seen, by such woman, or intrudes upon the privacy of such woman.
  6. Section 506 in IPC, Punishment for criminal intimidation, Whoever commits, the offence of criminal intimidation shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both; If threat be to cause death or grievous hurt, etc.
  7. The objective of 504 IPC section is to prevent the intentional use of abusive language amounting to insult, giving rise to provocations causing the person against whom such words are used to commit breach of peace.
  8. The Section 67 of IT Act 2000, Punishment for publishing or transmitting obscene material in electronic form. Punishment for publishing or transmitting of material containing sexually explicit act, etc, in electronic form.
  9. Cognizable are heinous crimes, whereas non-cognizable offences are not so serious. Cognizable encompasses murder, rape, theft, kidnapping, counterfeiting, etc. On the contrary, non-cognizable offences include offences like forgery, cheating, assault, defamation and so forth.

 Other Examples:

  1.  In 1988, IAS officer Rupan Deol Bajaj case prosecuted Punjab’s super-policeman K.P.S. Gill, for outraging her modesty. Mr. Gill’s conviction was maintained right up to the Supreme Court but he was released on probation and suffered no imprisonment.
  2. In the Mathura rape case of 1978, the Supreme Court’s acquittal of the policeman, Tukaram, earned it a stinging rebuke from legal scholars that “consent involves submission, but the converse is not necessarily true”.
  3. The founder-editor of a magazine, Tarun Tejpal’s trial case for an alleged digital rape, in 2013, of his subordinate in a hotel lift, is still pending trial in a court in Goa.

Way forward:

  • The Ramani verdict is a huge moral vindication of the #MeToo movement, and will, hopefully, serve to deter powerful men from using the defamation law to silence survivors. But we are still very far away from ensuring workplaces free of sexual harassment for every woman, every transperson.
  • This case open the door for many more women will now be emboldened to resist harassment at the workplace and elsewhere. Hopefully a few men are now deterred from trading power and position to secure sexual favors.
  • Why the acquittal on a charge of defamation by a victim of sexual harassment is being celebrated when the alleged perpetrator has faced no criminal prosecution at all.
  • In the name of good deed in a naughty world when contrasted against a series of cases where the legal process has failed to bring closure and justice to women.
  • The Indian constitution granted men and women equally have the right to an adequate means of livelihood, that there is equal pay for both men and women, provide free and compulsory education for children and duty to improve public health.

Question

Whether the recent Supreme Court Judgement on defamationcan settle the tussle between the defamation and defenceunder the women laws.

Too many IITs, unrealistic expectations.

Why in News: –

The recent decision of the University Grants Commission to permit select IITs under the ‘Institutions of Eminence’ category to set up campuses abroad could further weaken these already stretched institutions.

Syllabus: –

GS-2: Issues relating to development and management of Social Sector/Services relating to Health, Education, Human Resources.

It is time to rethink the changing role and mandate of IITs in order to ensure that quality and focus are maintained and by prioritising the needs of India, but with a 21st century twist.

 What the IITs?

  • The original five IITs were established in the 1950s and early 1960s Four had a foreign collaborator: IIT Bombay (the Soviet Union), IIT Madras (Germany), IIT Kanpur (the United States), and IIT Delhi (the United Kingdom).
  • What the IITs Offer: –Currently, there are 23 IITs. After setting up IIT Delhi in 1961, it took another 34 years to establish the sixth IIT in Guwahati (1994). Since then, 17 more IITs have been established, including several that resulted from upgrading existing institutions.
  • The IITs focused exclusively on technology, innovation, research and engineering.
  • They later added the humanities and social sciences, but these programmes were modest until the 2020 National Education Policy emphasised the IITs should focus more on “holistic and multidisciplinary education”.
  1.  The IITs started as undergraduate institutions; they gradually added small post-graduate programmers, but some are now adding significant post-graduate offerings. IIT-Bombay’s student enrolment, for example, was 58% post-graduate during 2019-20.
  2. The IITs were, and are, self-consciously elite institutions aiming at the highest international academic standards — a tradition which, in our view, is important but increasingly difficult to maintain.
  3. Around 7,00,000 students sit for the national engineering entrance examination for the IITs and several other elite institutions each year and a vast majority of them target the 16,000-plus seats available in the 23 IITs

The dropout rates at the IITs are infinitesimal and declining, from 2.25% in

  1. 2015-16 to 0.68% in 2019-20.

 The concerns with IITs:

  1. According to data available with the Council of Indian Institutes of Technology, the IITs are small institutions with average student enrolments in the five older IITs of around 10,000.
  2. Some of the newer ones remain quite small, with fewer than 400 students. The older IITs have faculties of around 1,000, while some of the new ones, such as those in Palakkad and Jammu, employ 100.
  3. Most of the IITs suffer from a severe shortage of professors. For example, IIT Dhanbad is approved to hire 781 instructors but only 301 positions were filled as of January 2021.

  Recent Developments:

  1.  The IITs could not attract a sufficient number of young faculties to fill vacancies resulting from retirements.
  2. The emerging IT and related industries in India offered much more attractive salaries and exciting work opportunities, and many were lured to universities and industry in other countries.
  3. The government dramatically expanded the number of IITs, spreading them around the country. Most of the new IITs are located in smaller towns such as Mandi (Himachal Pradesh), Palakkad (Kerala), Dharwad (Karnataka), and others.

What are the Solutions: –

  1. It is important to provide educational opportunities outside the major metropolitan areas; top institutions are seldom located far away from urban amenities.
  2.  Facilities and infrastructure are unlikely to be “world class.”
  3. It is, thus, inevitable that quality will decline and the “IIT brand” diluted.
  4. Another area is the lack of correlation between the local needs and IITs. Most of the IITs and other prominent “Institutes of National Importance” are ‘academic enclaves’ with little connection with their regions.
  5. The State governments most effectively utilising the presence of IITs in the local milieu through knowledge sharing networks involving universities, colleges and schools, and local industries and firms.
  6. There are few community outreaches programmes.
  7. Such an approach could prevent disruption, such as that occurring in Goa, where local groups are resisting locating a new IIT in their region.

 Modern Solutions: –

  1. While excellent engineering/STEM (science, technology, engineering and mathematics) institutions are more needed, they all do not have to be IITs.
  2. Perhaps 10 to 12 “real” IITs located near major cities are practical for India
  3.  A more limited “IIT system” needs to be funded at “world class” levels and staffed by “world class” faculty, perhaps with some recruited from top universities internationally.
  4. The Decision to liberalise the recruitment rules to attract more foreign faculty is a good step in the right direction.
  5. the IITs need to pay attention to internationalization beyond sending their brightest graduates abroad and recruiting Indians with foreign PhDs;
  6.  Starting the overseas branches is a bad idea, but in-depth collaboration with the best global universities, and hiring foreign faculty.
  7. The IITs need robust policies to attract international students. 

Way Forward

  1. IITs are institutes of national importance established and funded by the central government (MHRD), whereas IITs are funded both by the government and the private sector, and are usually set up on a PPP model.
  2. There are some IITs established by state governments, too. IITs provide courses in all kinds of engineering, management and even medical sciences need center –state coordination and co-operation.
  3. IITs are technical educational institutes, with an innovative governance structure that allows them to provide an exceptional education model.
  4. They have been set-up with the key objective of addressing the challenges faced by the Indian technology, innovation, research and engineering industry must be continued.

Question

The quality of IITs in India requires major improvements to make it internationally competitive. Do you think that the recent decision of the University Grants Commission to permit select IITs under the ‘Institutions of Eminence’ category would help improve the quality of higher and technical education in the country? Discuss.

The Quad endures

Why in News:

 –Latest Quad meeting, soon after agreement with China on disengagement, shows India’s interest is not tactical but strategic

Syllabus: –

What is ‘Quad’?

  • A gathering of four nations with a “checkered history”, Quad was started in 2007 to maintain vital interests in the Indo-Pacific locale and as a reaction to the developing Chinese clout.
  • In any case, its birthplaces return to the hour of the December 2004 Tsunami, when India embraced salvage and aid ventures for itself and the other influenced adjoining nations, and was joined by the US, Australia and Japan.

Significance of Quad for India: –

  • In India, Australia and other Indo-Pacific nations, we have been routinely immersed with critique about the ‘Quad’, the casual name for a gathering of nations containing the United States, Japan, India and Australia.
  • The Quad is a military partnership to contain China and its general concept is provocative, troublesome and superfluous.
  • This is the perspective on certain pundits in the four nations, yet additionally numerous in China and Southeast Asia.
  • The accusatory finger is typically pointed at India, here and there at Australia, and sporadically at the United States after Donald Trump’s political race as president.
  • The two perspectives generally mischaracterise the Quad and its goals. For the present, it is simply an administrative level unfamiliar service drove discourse that meets incidentally following a 10-year rest.
  • While the four nations have led some military exercises togetherthe Quad isn’t a protection exchange, substantially less a collusion.
  • It fills the restricted need of political flagging and improves coordination among a bunch of similar and proficient sea powers in the Indo-Pacific.
  • With the Quad indeed figuring conspicuously in the public safety talk, alternate points of view have jumped up on what sway it can have on China and its desire soon.

  • In India, Australia and other Indo-Pacific nations, we have been routinely immersed with critique about the ‘Quad’, the casual name for a gathering of nations containing the United States, Japan, India and Australia.
  • The Quad is a military partnership to contain China and its general concept is provocative, troublesome and superfluous.
  • This is the perspective on certain pundits in the four nations, yet additionally numerous in China and Southeast Asia.
  • The accusatory finger is typically pointed at India, here and there at Australia, and sporadically at the United States after Donald Trump’s political race as president.
  • The two perspectives generally mischaracterise the Quad and its goals. For the present, it is simply an administrative level unfamiliar service drove discourse that meets incidentally following a 10-year rest.
  • While the four nations have led some military exercises togetherthe Quad isn’t a protection exchange, substantially less a collusion.
  • It fills the restricted need of political flagging and improves coordination among a bunch of similar and proficient sea powers in the Indo-Pacific.
  • With the Quad indeed figuring conspicuously in the public safety talk, alternate points of view have jumped up on what sway it can have on China and its desire soon.

The ‘China Connect’

  • The COVID-19 pandemic has upset examples of globalization.
  • However, globalization is profoundly implanted in the emanant worldwide request and it would be hard for India to totally pull out from its relationship with China.
  • Nonetheless, New Delhi understands that a guarantee to a ‘Quad Plus’ account won’t go unchallenged by China, respectively or multilaterally.
  • China’s relations with the Quad nations and ‘Quad Plus’ partaking nations will keep on existing.
  • Moreover, the ‘Quad Plus’ thought is as yet youthful, existing generally in media speech, and without an institutional structure.
  • The majority of the taking an interest nation in the ‘Quad Plus’ structure, for example, Brazil, South Korea and Vietnam would likewise be careful in taking part in an enemy of China story, as every one of them share solid monetary binds with Beijing.
  • All things considered, such a thought serves India’s essential interest in acquiring power multilaterally, by reinforcing its relations with nations that are basic to the arising request.
  • India is ready to exploit the dissemination of forces, stretching out past the Quad Plus nations.
  • Such a cycle permits India to draw in more profound in essential, military and financial impact with nations that are basic to India’s developing fortune in the Indo-Pacific.
  • All in all, Quad Plus enhancements a ‘Passage of Communication’ for India past the Quad nations, essentially with Brazil, Israel, Vietnam and South Korea, and permits it to facilitate a ‘Mainland Connect’ thought that its comprehensive Indo-Pacific standpoint has been pitching for quite a while.

Way forward

  • The Indo-Pacific Quad basically addresses an association of Middle Powers holding with one superpower, however which has encountered an overall decrease in its force.
  • The way things are the Quad, by virtue of its inward force setup, exhibits a serious level of financial and military between reliance, instead of a subjugated progressive system ruled over by Washington.
  • Perceiving that the Middle Powers need to collaborate yet save key space for themselves.
  • The model of the only remaining century of peace agreements with a hefty in-country US troop presence,” isn’t really the Quad’s future.

Question

The Quadrilateral security framework involving Australia, India, Japan and the United States is considered a unique foreign policy initiative of the Indian Government to improve its maritime security. Does the project have a strategic dimension? Discuss.

Share With Your Friends

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on print
Print

Buy This Magazine at Just @29 Rs.

Click On Magazine Image  to Buy.

Buy This Magazine at Just @59 Rs.

Click On Magazine Image  to Buy.

Buy This Magazine at Just @49 Rs.

Click On Magazine Image  to Buy.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x